Two or more entities may wish to engage in a
project together. Business, legal and tax issues immediately
arise. This article does not deal with tax issues.
Some issues that arise are as follows:
1. what will the parties contribute to the
project?
2. what will be the responsibilities of the
parties?
3. how will the project be controlled?
4. how will decisions be made?
5. what will the parties receive from the
project?
6. what happens when the project is
complete?
7. how is the relationship between the
parties terminated in different situations?
8. if property is to be obtained, how will
title to the property be held?
9. how will third party liability be dealt
with?
These issues can be addressed, in part, by the
choice of the appropriate legal entity to be used in respect of
the project. Tax issues will also determine the choice of the
legal entity. This article will only deal with non-tax
considerations.
Essentially the parties to the project have a
choice between 4 legal entities: corporation, partnership, limited
partnership and joint venture.
If the parties are only interested in a
relationship for the duration of the one project the options of
incorporation and partnership may not be desirable. In many cases
a joint venture is chosen for this reason and for tax reasons.
If the parties are not careful however, they
may inadvertently form a partnership. Under the Partnership Act,
parties that carry on business together with a view to profit may
be deemed to be a partnership. If the parties are deemed to be a
partnership, the provisions of the Partnership Act will
apply. Absent agreement to the contrary, many of the issues set
out above will be answered by the provisions of the Partnership
Act. These provisions may not be what the parties desire.
Further, the provisions of the Partnership Act pertaining
to the liability of partners to one another and to third parties
may be particularly objectionable. A partnership agreement allows
the partners to "contract out" of the implied provisions
of the Partnership Act to a certain extent. Generally
speaking, partners cannot in a partnership agreement affect the
rights of third parties.
A joint venture agreement between the parties
is another way of avoiding the implications of the Partnership
Act. In such an agreement the parties may expressly provide
that they are not partners. Further, they may deal with the above
listed issues in a way that is different from the structure of the
Partnership Act. Liability to third parties may or may not
be affected by the existence of a joint venture agreement
depending on a variety of factors.
Partnership agreements and joint venture agreements may be
complicated. It is strongly recommended that parties seek legal
and tax advice before entering into either a partnership or a
joint venture arrangement.